Monday, 3 May 2021

The Assembly Women (Ecclesiazusae or Contionantes) - Aristophanes

Aka The Assemblywomen; (Ecclesiazusae; Ἐκκλησιάζουσαι Ekklesiazousai) Congresswomen, Women in Parliament, Women in Power, and A Parliament of Women.

There are no surviving details when this play was first performed. From internal information in the play it seems it was produced around 393-391 BC, around the time of the Corinthian War. 

Corinthian War - Wikipedia

Skene
A significant portion of the play revolves around the Pnyx, which was the actual Athenian assembly meeting place on a hill overlooking the Agora. Other scenes may depict various streets or public areas in ancient Athens.

Dramatis Personae

Praxagora (The main character who devises the plan for women to take over the Assembly). Her name means "woman who takes action in a public place and space".
Blepyrus (Praxagora's husband). 
Chorus (Group of women disguised as men)
Chremes (A citizen returning from the Assembly meeting)
Citizen/Selfish Man (A man opposed to sharing wealth under the new female-led government)
Epigenes (A young man struggling with the new law requiring him to sleep with an old woman first)

Plot

In Aristophanes' comedy, Assemblywomen, frustration with the Athenian government fuels a radical plan by a woman named Praxagora, the wife of Blepyrus, to take power:-

Disgruntled Women, Daring Plan: Praxagora, tired of the men's political ineptitude, hatches a plan to seize power. The women of Athens plan to disguise themselves as men and in a coup d'état take control of the citizens' Assembly [Ecclesia]. Together they will form a new social order in which women will hold all the power.

The Women take over of the Assembly: The women using their clever disguises succeed in doing this. They manage to infiltrate the Assembly and to vote themselves into leadership. Athens is going to be reformed in a major way: in session at the Assembly they manage to pass a series of measures, including the abolition of private property, and institute the communal sharing of wives, and the equal distribution of wealth.

Thus the women set up a kind of Communist Utopia: Praxagora enacts a series of reforms: Private property is abolished, and everything, including wives, is to be shared communally.  Public buildings are turned into communal dining halls. Dividing walls between households are abolished, as are families too.

Equality Rules (Even in Love): Forget wealth and status determining relationships between men and women; love and procreation become the prime duties for everyone – young, old, attractive, and ugly – all are to share equally the burden of mating and giving birth to the next generation. Slaves are excluded from these proposals, though. As the new order takes hold, chaos ensues as traditional gender roles are overturned, and men find themselves subjected to the whims of their wives. In the new order and under the regime of women, social inequality, based on wealth, age, and beauty are abolished, and along with them the principal causes of selfishness too.

Men's Grumbling Acceptance: The men, initially resistant, eventually find some benefits in this new arrangement and system, especially the readily available meals in the public dining halls. Only the selfish ones who hoard possessions are unhappy.

So, is this a happy-ever-after situation? Two main causes bring the new regime down: some cling to the old order wanting to hold onto its privileges, especially their desire to hold onto property; the second involves the new regime's principle of sexual equality and its system of giving priority to the old and ugly - it just doesn't work. 

Aristophanes' play uses bawdy and absurd humour to satirise the Athenian government and society's norms. The ending is open to interpretation. While the women appear to be in control, the long-term viability of this unusual social experiment remains unclear. In the end, the absurdity of rule by women becomes apparent, and the natural order according to Aristophanes is restored, albeit with a lesson learned about the dangers of radical social experimentation.

References

Assemblywomen - Wikipedia

A Guide to Ancient Greek Drama: Synopsis of Aristophanes' Assembly-Women

Crowell's handbook of classical drama pp 123- : Hathorn, Richmond Y. - Internet Archive

Dithyramb, Tragedy and Comedy pp. 327-328 - Internet Archive
Analysis of Play: Ecclesiazusae

Aristophanes: Ecclesiazusae - Tom's Learning Notes

Ecclesiazusae - Aristophanes - Ancient Greece - Classical Literature

Assemblywomen by Aristophanes - GreekMythology.Com

Ecclesiazusae - World History Encyclopedia

Ecclesiazusae - World History Encyclopedia

The Ecclesiazusae Summary - SuperSummary

Praxagora Study Resources - Course Hero

Google Scholar Search = Aristophanes Ecclesiazusae

JStor Search = Aristophanes Ecclesiazusae

Core UK Search = Aristophanes+Ecclesiazusae

Library of Congress Search = Aristophanes+Ecclesiazusae

Hulley, Karl K. “The Prologue of the Ecclesiazusae.” The Classical Weekly, vol. 46, no. 9, 1953, pp. 129–131. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/4343346.


Olson, S. Douglas. “Anonymous Male Parts in Aristophanes’ Ecclesiazusae and the Identity of the Δεσπότης.” The Classical Quarterly, vol. 41, no. 1, Cambridge University Press, 1991, pp. 36–40, http://www.jstor.org/stable/639021.

Tsoumpra, Natalia. “Undressing and Cross-Dressing: Costume, Ritual, and Female Empowerment in Aristophanes.” Illinois Classical Studies, vol. 45, no. 2, University of Illinois Press, 2020, pp. 368–98, https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5406/illiclasstud.45.2.0368.

Casement, William. “Political Theory in Aristophanes’ Ecclesiazusae.” Journal of Thought, vol. 21, no. 4, Caddo Gap Press, 1986, pp. 64–79, http://www.jstor.org/stable/42589924.

Greek Versions

Aristophanes: Ecclesiazusae on JSTOR Aris & Phillips

Aristophanis Ecclesiazusae: editit J. van Leeuwen - Internet Archive

Aristophanous komoidiai. Comedies Volume V Aristophanes  Frogs Ecclesiazusae- Internet Archive

Aristophanis Ecclesiazusae edited by J.W. Van Leeuwen

Loeb Edition: L179 Aristophanes III Lysistrata Thesmophoriazusae Ecclesiazusae Plutus - B.B. Rogers

Translations

Delphi Complete Works of Aristophanes: Assemblywomen

The Congresswomen (Ecclesiazusae) trans by Douglass Parker

Birds and Other Plays (Oxford World's Classics) : Aristophanes -  Internet Archive

The knights ; [and], Peace ; [and], the birds ; [and], the assemblywomen ; [and], Wealth : Aristophanes : - Internet Archive

Aristophanes; tr. Alan H. Sommerstein (1998). Ecclesiazusae. Volume 10 of Comedies of Aristophanes. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-85668-708-2.

The Knights; Peace; Wealth; The Birds ; The Assemblywomen [1986]
by Aristophanes; Translated by David Barrett and Alan H. Sommerstein
ISBN 0140443320 9780140443325
https://archive.org/details/knightspeacewea00aris/mode/1up

A Detailed Analysis and Plot Summary of Aristophanes' Ecclesiazusae

I. Introduction

Aristophanes stands as a towering figure in the realm of Ancient Greek comedy, particularly within the genre known as Old Comedy.1 This form of dramatic expression, flourishing in Athens during the 5th century BCE, was characterized by its bold political satire, unrestrained fantasy, overt obscenity, and the prominent role played by the chorus.3 The surviving works of Aristophanes offer an invaluable lens through which to understand the intricacies of Athenian society, its political landscape, and the prevailing cultural norms of the late 5th and early 4th centuries BCE.1 His plays engaged directly with the issues of the day, offering comedic commentary on everything from the Peloponnesian War to the rise of sophistry, making them essential resources for comprehending this pivotal period in Western history.

Among Aristophanes' significant contributions to this genre is his play Ecclesiazusae, believed to have been produced around 391 BCE.6 This period followed the tumultuous Peloponnesian War, a conflict that had profoundly impacted Athens, leading to the re-establishment of a democratic government amidst ongoing tensions and conflicts.8 Against this backdrop of societal uncertainty, Ecclesiazusae presents a radical and imaginative premise: the women of Athens orchestrate a takeover of the city's government.5 The play delves into a range of compelling themes, including the complexities of gender roles, the dynamics of power, the possibilities of societal reform, and the concept of communal living.5 Notably, Ecclesiazusae is often discussed in relation to early utopian ideas, with scholars noting potential connections and influences on Plato's later work, The Republic.6 The play can be seen as a reflection of the anxieties and uncertainties that permeated post-war Athens, using a fantastical scenario to explore radical solutions to the multifaceted problems facing the city.8

This report aims to provide a comprehensive and detailed examination of Aristophanes' Ecclesiazusae. It will offer a thorough scene-by-scene analysis of the play, meticulously outlining the key actions, characters, and dialogue within each segment. Furthermore, it will present a complete plot summary, tracing the narrative arc from its inciting incident to its conclusion. Throughout this analysis, specific references will be made to line numbers within the original Ancient Greek text, primarily drawing from the edition available through the Perseus Digital Library.26 Finally, the report will delve into the major themes present in the play, exploring their significance within the context of Athenian society and their broader implications for the study of classical literature and political thought.

II. Detailed Scene-by-Scene Analysis

Ecclesiazusae unfolds in a series of episodes, each contributing to the development of its central comedic premise and its exploration of radical social change. The following analysis breaks down the play scene by scene, referencing line numbers where possible based on the Perseus Digital Library edition.

A. Scene 1: Prologue (Lines 1-289)

The play opens in the pre-dawn hours in a public square in Athens, with the façades of two houses forming the backdrop and an alleyway situated between them.26 Praxagora, the central figure of the play, enters cautiously, carrying a lit lantern.26 Her opening lines, delivered in a high tragic style, are addressed to the lamp, revealing her audacious plot to seize control of the Athenian government by having the women disguise themselves as men and vote in the Assembly.24 This mock-heroic address to an inanimate object immediately establishes a tone of subversive irony, hinting at the unconventional nature of the events to follow.24 Praxagora expresses her frustration with the current state of affairs and her belief that women can govern Athens more effectively than men.

As dawn approaches, other women, who are part of Praxagora's conspiracy, begin to arrive.8 They are all disguised in men's clothing, wearing false beards, and carrying staffs and men's sandals, having taken these items from their husbands.26 Their initial dialogue reveals the challenges they faced in securing their disguises and slipping away unnoticed. Praxagora chastises them for their tardiness, emphasizing the importance of arriving early at the Assembly to secure advantageous positions.8 The women then engage in a rehearsal of how they will speak and behave as men in the Assembly.15 This practice session is filled with comedic moments as the women struggle to adopt masculine mannerisms, make mistakes such as swearing by female deities instead of male ones, and complain about the discomfort of their male attire.16

Recognizing the difficulty some of the women are having in maintaining their male personas, Praxagora decides that she will be the primary speaker in the Assembly.15 She then practices her speech, outlining the myriad reasons why women are better suited to govern Athens, citing their supposed superior abilities in managing households, keeping secrets, and avoiding the corruption that plagues male politicians.8 Praxagora argues that women are inherently more trustworthy, less prone to innovation, and more devoted to the welfare of the state.8 The women express their enthusiastic agreement with Praxagora's plan and her persuasive rhetoric.28 With their strategy solidified, the women prepare to depart for the Assembly, ready to implement their audacious scheme.28 The extended nature of this opening scene serves to establish the elaborate deception at the heart of the play and to generate humor from the women's often clumsy attempts to pass as men.11

B. Scene 2: Parodos (Lines 290-310)

As the women leave for the Assembly, the Chorus, still in their male disguises, performs the Parodos, their entrance song and dance.28 They address the Athenian citizens (the audience), reminding themselves and each other to maintain their male facade and to refer to themselves only as men.28 The Chorus emphasizes the importance of not revealing their true identities, warning of the potential consequences if their nighttime plot is discovered.28 Their song also touches upon the motivations of Athenian citizens attending the Assembly, noting that only those who arrive at daybreak, looking disheveled and having subsisted on meager snacks, will receive the triobolus, the payment for attendance.28 The Chorus urges each other to walk briskly, to demand their fee first, and then to vote in favor of what will benefit their "fellow-citizens" (initially slipping and saying "partisans," highlighting the artificiality of their disguise).28 They express their intention to drive away the men who used to stay home when the payment was only an obolus, as now the Pnyx is overly crowded.28 The Chorus reminisces about a past era when citizens served without pay, bringing their own simple meals, contrasting it with the present where citizens are as mercenary as stonemasons, eager to earn their three obols.28 This choral passage acts as a bridge between the initial planning of the conspiracy and the women's active participation in the political sphere, while also offering a satirical commentary on the perceived motivations and behaviors within the Athenian democratic process.28

C. Scene 3: Episode 1 (Lines 311-477)

The scene shifts to outside the house of Blepyrus, Praxagora's husband.28 Blepyrus emerges from his home, comically attired in his wife's saffron robe and Persian slippers.8 He is bewildered by his wife's absence at such an early hour and equally perplexed by the disappearance of his own cloak and shoes.8 His initial dialogue reveals his confusion and his suspicion that his wife's unusual behavior is likely due to some nefarious purpose.28 He laments his advanced age at the time of his marriage, further emphasizing his current discomfiture.

Soon, a Man, Blepyrus's neighbor, appears at his window and recognizes Blepyrus in his wife's attire, prompting a humorous exchange about his appearance.28 Blepyrus explains his predicament, stating that he grabbed his wife's tunic in the darkness when he couldn't find his own clothes. The neighbor reveals that his own wife has also disappeared, taking his cloak and, even more inconveniently, his shoes.28 Blepyrus then encounters Chremes, who is returning from the Assembly.8 Chremes greets Blepyrus, noticing his peculiar attire, and proceeds to inform him about the extraordinary events that transpired at the Assembly.28 He recounts how the Prytanes initiated a discussion about measures to ensure the city's safety, and various individuals offered their proposals.28 Chremes then describes how a handsome young man, resembling young Nicias, addressed the tribune and proposed that the direction of Athenian affairs be entrusted to the women.8 This proposal was met with enthusiastic applause from the shoemakers present, while the country-folk groaned in disapproval.28 Chremes explains that the orator (Praxagora in disguise) argued passionately for women's superior qualities, criticizing men as rogues, thieves, and informers.8 Ultimately, the Assembly voted in favor of this unprecedented measure, deciding to hand over the governance of Athens to the women, as it was the only option they had not yet tried.8 Blepyrus, still unaware that the eloquent young orator was his own wife, expresses his surprise and raises questions about the practical implications of this decision, wondering if women will now take on traditionally male roles such as serving on juries.8 This scene serves to introduce the male reaction to the women's successful coup, highlighting the absurdity of the situation through Blepyrus's comical appearance and his bewildered inquiries.17

D. Scene 4: Episode 2 (Lines 478-729)

Praxagora returns home, still dressed in men's attire, and is immediately confronted by Blepyrus regarding her whereabouts and the disappearance of his clothes.8 Praxagora initially feigns ignorance about the events at the Assembly.28 However, when Blepyrus informs her of the decision to entrust the city's governance to women, she drops her act and enthusiastically declares it a momentous day for Athens, anticipating an end to corruption and various other societal ills.8 She then proceeds to explain the radical reforms that the new female government will implement.8 These include the abolition of private property in favor of a common stock of essentials to be shared equally among all citizens, the elimination of money, the establishment of communal meals in public dining halls created from repurposed courthouses and porticos, and the abolition of marriage, allowing men and women to sleep with whomever they desire.8 A particularly striking aspect of these reforms is the provision for sexual equality with a peculiar twist: the new law dictates that attractive young men and women must first have sexual relations with older, less desirable partners before they can be with someone of their own choosing.8 Praxagora argues that this will ensure that everyone, regardless of their physical appearance, has the opportunity for love and companionship.17 Blepyrus reacts to these revolutionary changes with a mixture of confusion and concern, often focusing on how these new laws will affect his personal comfort and daily life.8 This scene is pivotal in revealing the core tenets of the women's new regime and exploring the comedic potential of such extreme societal restructuring, particularly concerning the fundamental aspects of property ownership and interpersonal relationships.6

E. Scene 5: Episode 3 (Lines 730-876)

The setting shifts to outside the house of another citizen.31 Here, we encounter a Citizen who is diligently bringing his possessions out of his house, preparing to hand them over to the common fund as mandated by the new laws.8 However, another character, known as the Selfish Man, appears and immediately expresses his skepticism and resistance to this communal system.8 The Selfish Man declares his intention to exploit the new system by benefiting from the communal resources, particularly the promised feast, without contributing any of his own property.8 He voices his cynicism, doubting that everyone will truly relinquish their possessions and expressing his unwillingness to be a fool by giving up his property while others hoard theirs.16 A Heraldess then arrives, announcing that a lavish communal feast has been prepared and that all citizens must present themselves before "Her Excellency the General" (Praxagora) to draw lots that will determine their dining arrangements for the day.11 Despite his earlier reluctance to contribute, the Selfish Man eagerly plans to attend the feast, hoping to partake in the communal meal while still retaining his private property.16 This episode introduces the first significant challenge to Praxagora's utopian vision, highlighting the practical difficulties of implementing a system based on communal ownership and the enduring presence of self-interest within human nature.11 The Selfish Man's character embodies the potential for individuals to exploit even the most idealistic systems for personal gain.

F. Scene 6: Episode 4 (Lines 877-1111)

The scene transitions to a different part of Athens, specifically featuring the houses of two prostitutes.11 An Old Woman is seen looking out of her window, lamenting the lack of male visitors, while a Young Girl appears at the window of the neighboring house.32 A brief and vulgar exchange of insults occurs between them before they retreat indoors.15 Shortly thereafter, a Young Man named Epigenes enters the scene, expressing his distress and frustration with the newly enacted laws governing sexual relationships.10 He is eager to meet with the Young Girl he desires, but he is acutely aware of the law that requires him to first fulfill the desires of any older, less attractive woman who might claim him.10 His lament highlights the potentially unpleasant consequences of the enforced sexual equality. As Epigenes and the Young Girl briefly express their mutual affection, their tryst is interrupted by the sudden appearance of the Old Woman from the first house.10 Citing the new law, she attempts to force Epigenes to sleep with her first.10 A farcical struggle ensues, with the Young Girl attempting to intervene, only to be joined by two more increasingly hideous Old Women who also assert their legal right to Epigenes.10 Despite his vehement protests, the three Old Women overpower and drag Epigenes into one of their houses.10 This scene, while highly comedic, serves as a pointedly satirical critique of the enforced sexual equality, revealing its potentially grotesque and undesirable outcomes.15

G. Scene 7: Exodos (Lines 1112-1183)

The play concludes with the Exodos, a final scene that often involves a departure or celebration.13 Praxagora's Maid appears, seemingly intoxicated, and enthusiastically praises the new regime and its many benefits.31 She invites Blepyrus, who is now dressed in more appropriate attire, to join the communal feast, highlighting the abundance and variety of the dishes available.31 Blepyrus, however, responds with a somewhat sarcastic remark about his own idea of sharing the food with all the Athenian citizens, perhaps hinting at a lingering skepticism or a sense of the absurdity of the situation.31 The play ends with Blepyrus cheerfully making his way to the banquet, accompanied by young dancing girls.8 The Chorus may have offered some final remarks before exiting, although the provided snippets do not detail this aspect of the play's conclusion.32 The ending of Ecclesiazusae is somewhat ambiguous. While it culminates in the promise of a communal feast and apparent celebration, the earlier resistance from the Selfish Man and the unsettling episode with Epigenes and the Old Women suggest that the implementation of Praxagora's radical utopian vision may not be entirely smooth or universally embraced.10

III. Comprehensive Plot Summary

Aristophanes' Ecclesiazusae opens with Praxagora, an Athenian housewife, orchestrating a secret plan with other women to seize control of the Athenian government. Disguised as men by wearing their husbands' clothes and false beards, the women infiltrate the Assembly before dawn. Praxagora, a skilled orator, convinces the male citizens to hand over the reins of power to the women, arguing that they are better equipped to govern due to their experience in managing households and their inherent trustworthiness. The men, perhaps out of sheer desperation or a desire for novelty, agree to this unprecedented transfer of power.

Once in control, Praxagora introduces a series of radical reforms aimed at creating a utopian society based on communal principles. Private property is abolished, with all possessions to be shared equally among the citizens. Money is deemed obsolete, and communal meals are to be held in public dining halls. Marriage is dissolved, and men and women are free to engage in sexual relationships with whomever they choose, albeit with the stipulation that younger, more attractive individuals must first partner with older, less desirable ones.

The play follows the initial reactions and consequences of these sweeping changes. Blepyrus, Praxagora's husband, is initially confused by his wife's actions and the strange news from the Assembly. When Praxagora reveals the new laws to him, he expresses a mixture of bewilderment and concern. A Selfish Man is introduced who intends to exploit the communal system without contributing his own wealth, highlighting the challenges of implementing such a radical social structure. A particularly farcical episode involves a young man, Epigenes, who is eager to be with his young lover but is forcibly claimed by a succession of elderly and unattractive women, in accordance with the new law of enforced sexual equality.

The play concludes with a scene of apparent communal harmony as citizens prepare to partake in a grand feast, celebrating the new female-led government. However, the underlying tensions and the absurdities revealed throughout the play leave the audience with a sense that this utopian experiment may not be as idyllic or sustainable as Praxagora envisions. The ending is ambiguous, suggesting that while the women have successfully taken power and implemented their reforms, the long-term success and universal acceptance of this radical social order remain uncertain.

IV. Major Themes and Analysis

Ecclesiazusae is a rich tapestry of comedic elements woven together to explore a range of significant themes relevant to Athenian society of the late 4th century BCE and beyond.

A. Satire of Athenian Politics and Society:

At its core, Ecclesiazusae is a biting satire of Athenian politics and society.3 Aristophanes uses the outlandish scenario of women taking over the government to lampoon the perceived incompetence, corruption, and self-interest of the male leaders of his time.8 Through Praxagora's speeches and the subsequent implementation of her radical reforms, the play critiques the existing political system and the behavior of Athenian citizens, particularly their perceived greed and fickleness. The humor often arises from inverting traditional gender roles, placing women in positions of authority and depicting men as passive, foolish, or easily manipulated, thereby satirizing the established power dynamics.4 The very act of women disguising themselves as men to participate in the Assembly, a space traditionally exclusive to male citizens, underscores the limitations placed on women in Athenian society and serves as a satirical commentary on this exclusion.12

B. Gender Roles and Power Dynamics:

The play offers a fascinating exploration of traditional gender roles and the potential consequences of their reversal.4 Praxagora emerges as a strong and articulate female leader, driven by a belief in women's superior ability to govern.8 Her vision for a new social order challenges the patriarchal norms of Athenian society. In contrast, male characters like Blepyrus are often portrayed as somewhat dense, more concerned with their personal comforts than with the complexities of governance.8 The play humorously depicts the disruption of traditional power dynamics, with women assuming control and men adapting, sometimes awkwardly, to their new roles. This reversal allows Aristophanes to question the inherent assumptions about the capabilities and roles of men and women in society.

C. Utopianism and Communal Living:

Ecclesiazusae can be considered an early example of utopian literature, presenting an imagined ideal society based on communal principles.5 The reforms proposed by Praxagora – communal property, shared meals, the abolition of private wealth and marriage – reflect a vision of a society where resources are distributed equally and the traditional structures of family and ownership are dismantled.8 However, the play also explores the inherent challenges and potential absurdities of such a system. The character of the Selfish Man highlights the difficulty of eradicating self-interest, while the episode with the old women and Epigenes satirizes the forced nature of the sexual equality, suggesting the potential for unintended and unpleasant consequences.10 Through this comedic lens, Aristophanes seems to be questioning the feasibility and desirability of a purely communal society.

D. Comedic Elements and Satirical Devices:

Aristophanes masterfully employs a variety of comedic elements and satirical devices throughout Ecclesiazusae.3 Farce is evident in the exaggerated situations, such as the women's clumsy disguises and the chaotic pursuit of Epigenes by the old women. Obscenity and crude humor are present in the dialogue and certain scenarios, reflecting the conventions of Old Comedy. Wordplay and irony are used extensively to create comedic effects and to subtly convey the play's satirical message.3 The prolonged prologue, focusing on the women's attempts to act like men, and the exaggerated scenarios involving the new laws are prime examples of Aristophanes' comedic technique.16 By making the audience laugh at the absurdities of the women's takeover and its consequences, Aristophanes makes his social and political commentary more engaging and impactful.4

E. Connection to Plato's Republic:

Scholars have long debated the relationship between Ecclesiazusae and Plato's Republic, which also explores themes of communal living and radical social restructuring.6 The similarities in their exploration of communal property, shared childcare (implied in Ecclesiazusae), and the role of women in society are striking.18 Some argue that Aristophanes' play, being earlier, may have influenced Plato's ideas, or that both works reflect broader intellectual currents circulating in Athens at the time, where concepts of ideal governance and societal organization were actively being discussed.18 It is also possible that Aristophanes' comedy serves as a satirical precursor to some of the more serious philosophical explorations found in Plato's work.18 Regardless of the exact nature of their connection, the parallels between Ecclesiazusae and The Republic highlight a shared intellectual landscape grappling with fundamental questions about the structure and ideals of human society.

V. Conclusion

Ecclesiazusae stands as a remarkable example of Aristophanic Old Comedy, blending a fantastical premise with sharp social and political satire. Through a detailed scene-by-scene examination, the play reveals a meticulously crafted narrative that follows the audacious plan of Athenian women to seize control of their city's government and implement a radical utopian agenda. From the initial clandestine meeting and the humorous attempts at masculine disguise to the chaotic implementation of communal laws and the farcical episode of enforced sexual equality, the play offers a rich tapestry of comedic moments.

The comprehensive plot summary underscores the play's central narrative arc, tracing the women's successful takeover and the subsequent unfolding of their revolutionary reforms. The analysis of major themes further illuminates the play's enduring significance. Aristophanes masterfully uses the exaggerated scenario to critique the political failings and social norms of his time, exploring the complexities of gender roles, the allure and challenges of utopian ideals, and the enduring power of self-interest. The connections drawn between Ecclesiazusae and Plato's Republic highlight the play's place within a broader intellectual discourse on ideal societal structures.

Ultimately, Ecclesiazusae remains a compelling work that continues to resonate with audiences today. Its comedic brilliance, coupled with its insightful commentary on power, gender, and the perennial human quest for a better society, solidifies its place as a significant contribution to classical literature and a valuable resource for understanding the social and political landscape of ancient Athens.

Key Valuable Tables:

  1. Table: Scene Breakdown of Ecclesiazusae

Scene Number

Approximate Line Numbers

Setting

Main Characters

Brief Summary of Action

1

1-289

Public square in Athens before dawn

Praxagora, First Woman, Second Woman, Chorus of Women (disguised as men)

Praxagora reveals the plot; women arrive in disguise and rehearse for the Assembly; Praxagora prepares her speech; they depart for the Assembly.

2

290-310

Public square, en route to the Pnyx

Chorus of Women (disguised as men)

The Chorus sings about maintaining their disguise and securing payment for attending the Assembly, offering commentary on Athenian political practices.

3

311-477

Outside Blepyrus's house

Blepyrus, Man (neighbour), Chremes

Blepyrus appears in his wife's clothes, confused; Chremes returns from the Assembly and informs him about the women's takeover.

4

478-729

In front of Blepyrus's house

Praxagora, Blepyrus

Praxagora returns and explains the new laws and radical reforms (communal property, sexual equality, etc.); Blepyrus reacts with confusion and concern.

5

730-876

In front of a citizen's house

Citizen (Selfish Man), Neighbor, Heraldess

A citizen prepares to hand over property; the Selfish Man expresses skepticism and plans to exploit the system; a Heraldess announces the communal feast.

6

877-1111

Different section of Athens, houses of prostitutes

First Old Woman, Young Girl, Young Man (Epigenes), Second Old Woman, Third Old Woman

A humorous and grotesque scene involving old women and a young girl; Epigenes laments the new sexual equality law and is forcibly taken by old women.

7

1112-1183

Public square, near communal dining halls (implied)

Praxagora's Maid, Blepyrus, Chorus, Young Dancing Girls

Praxagora's maid praises the new regime and invites Blepyrus to the feast; Blepyrus makes sarcastic comments; he goes to the feast with young dancing girls; the Chorus may offer final remarks.

  1. Table: Major Themes in Ecclesiazusae

Theme

Brief Description

Examples from the Play

Satire of Athenian Politics and Society

Critique of male leadership, corruption, and citizen behavior through the exaggerated scenario of female rule.

The women's complaints about male governance in the prologue; the Selfish Man's desire to exploit the system [Lines 730-876].

Gender Roles and Power Dynamics

Exploration of traditional roles and the consequences of their reversal; portrayal of strong female leadership and passive male characters.

Praxagora's leadership and her speeches; Blepyrus's confusion and reliance on Praxagora; the women disguising themselves as men [Lines 1-289].

Utopianism and Communal Living

Presentation of an ideal society based on communal principles, including shared property, meals, and the abolition of private wealth and marriage.

Praxagora's explanation of the new laws [Lines 478-729]; the announcement of the communal feast [Lines 730-876].

Comedic Elements and Satirical Devices

Use of farce, obscenity, wordplay, and irony to create humor and convey social and political commentary.

The women's struggles with their disguises [Lines 1-289]; the episode with Epigenes and the old women [Lines 877-1111].

Connection to Plato's Republic

Similarities in the exploration of communal living and social structures, suggesting a shared intellectual landscape.

Praxagora's reforms echoing some ideas in The Republic; the debate among scholars about influence and shared context.

Works cited

  1. The Ecclesiazusae (or Women in Council) () by Aristophanes - Goodreads, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2018.The_Ecclesiazusae_or_Women_in_Council_

  2. Aristophanes: Ecclesiazusae (Classic Commentaries) - Goodreads, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1976844.Aristophanes

  3. Aristophanes - Wikipedia, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristophanes

  4. ️Greek and Roman Comedy Unit 4 – Aristophanes: Themes in Greek Comedy - Fiveable, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://library.fiveable.me/greek-roman-comedy/unit-4

  5. Women at the Ecclesia | Ancient Greek, Comedy, Aristophanes - Britannica, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Women-at-the-Ecclesia

  6. Aristophanes: Ecclesiazusae (Aris & Phillips Classical Texts): 9780856687082 - Amazon.com, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.amazon.com/Aristophanes-Ecclesiazusae-Phillips-Classical-Texts/dp/0856687081

  7. Ecclesiazusae; (Greek Edition) - Aristophanes. R. G. Ussher (Editor, Introduction And Commentary): 9780198141914 - AbeBooks, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.abebooks.com/9780198141914/Ecclesiazusae-Greek-Edition-Aristophanes-Ussher-0198141912/plp

  8. Ecclesiazusae - World History Encyclopedia, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.worldhistory.org/Ecclesiazusae/

  9. 6 MEMORY AND THE RHETORIC OF ΣΩΤΗΡΙΑ IN ARISTOPHANES' ASSEMBLY WOMEN - Histos, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://histos.org/index.php/histos/article/download/105/99/108

  10. The Assembly Women (Ecclesiazusae or Contionantes) - Aristophanes - Ancient Greek Theatre, accessed on May 8, 2025, http://theatreofancientgreece.blogspot.com/2021/05/the-assembly-women-ecclesiazusae.html

  11. Assemblywomen by Aristophanes - Greek Mythology, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.greekmythology.com/Plays/Aristophanes/Assemblywomen_/assemblywomen_.html

  12. Ecclesiazusae · Classical Transvestism - Santa Clara University Digital Exhibits, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://dh.scu.edu/exhibits/exhibits/show/classical-transvestism/greek-tragedy-and-comedy/ecclesiazusae

  13. Aristophanes ECCLESIAZUSAE : Full text, in English - 1 - ELLOPOS net, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.ellopos.net/elpenor/greek-texts/ancient-greece/aristophanes/ecclesiazusae.asp

  14. Assemblywomen - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assemblywomen

  15. Assemblywomen - Wikipedia, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assemblywomen

  16. The Ecclesiazusae Summary - SuperSummary, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.supersummary.com/the-ecclesiazusae/summary/

  17. The Ecclesiazusae: Analysis of Major Characters | EBSCO Research Starters, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/ecclesiazusae-analysis-major-characters

  18. The Ecclesiazusae and the Republic | Vexillum, accessed on May 8, 2025, http://www.vexillumjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Ellis-The-Ecclesiazusae-and-the-Republic.pdf

  19. www.ebsco.com, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/ecclesiazusae-analysis-major-characters#:~:text=%22The%20Ecclesiazusae%22%20is%20a%20comedic,reform%20through%20its%20major%20characters.

  20. Modern Adaptations and Reperformances of Aristophanes' Ecclesiazusae - CAMWS, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://camws.org/sites/default/files/26558%20Modern%20Adaptations%20and%20Reperformances.pdf

  21. Aristophanes, Ecclesiazusae - Bryn Mawr Classical Review, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://bmcr.brynmawr.edu/2000/2000.11.17/

  22. Aristophanes: 'Ecclesiazusae' (Assemblywomen): An Extract | Sabidius.com, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.sabidius.com/ancient-greek/greek-texts/aristophanes-ecclesiazusae-assemblywomen-an-extract/

  23. humanitiesinstitute.org, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://humanitiesinstitute.org/__static/8462ad9d07faa3cb49f1ba70dcaec1c1/aristophanes-ecclesiazusae(2).pdf?dl=1

  24. Aristophanes-Assemblywomen.pdf - Classics Tuition, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.classicstuition.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Aristophanes-Assemblywomen.pdf

  25. POLITICS AND PERSUASION IN ARISTOPHANES' ECCLESIA,?,USAE - Brill, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://brill.com/downloadpdf/display/title/1301.pdf

  26. Aristophanes, Ecclesiazusae, line 1, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0030

  27. Aristophanes, Ecclesiazusae FW Hall and WM Geldart, Ed., accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0029

  28. The Ecclesiazusae by Aristophanes - The Internet Classics Archive, accessed on May 8, 2025, http://classics.mit.edu/Aristophanes/eccles.html

  29. ARISTOPHANES' ECCLESIAZUSAE, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://the-persians.co.uk/euripides/Ecclesiazousai.pdf

  30. Theodoridis, George - Classic Greek Plays in translation, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.poetryintranslation.com/PITBR/Greek/WomenInParliament.php

  31. The Staging and Meaning of Aristophanes' Assemblywomen, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/1300757

  32. Aristophanes, Ecclesiazusae, line 877, accessed on May 8, 2025, http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Aristoph.+Eccl.+878

  33. Lippman: Ugly is as Ugly Does: The Conclusion of the Ecclesiazusae - CAMWS, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://camws.org/meeting/2005/abstracts2005/lippman.html

34. ARISTOPHANES' ECCLESIAZVSAE AND THE REMAKING OF THE ΠΑΤΡΙΟΣ ΠΟΛΙΤΕΙΑ* | The Classical Quarterly | Cambridge Core, accessed on May 8, 2025, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/classical-quarterly/article/aristophanes-ecclesiazvsae-and-the-remaking-of-the/F942A9CCD2A64B77B83B67B866F46AAB

No comments:

Post a Comment